Published by Amir Lashkari
Hi
I am working about feasibility study of CEDI water treatment process for nitrate removal.
Can you share your experience and knowledge about this with me?
Continous electrode ionization (CEDI) has been a dream of some people that has been promoted as if the dream may come true in the reality of day. There are many dream that just don't seem to be workable for industrial applications.
When I was young and dumb, I obtained 99% ethanol by watching a small destination unit, closely monitoring the distillate temperature: Trying to achieve that on a large scale is more difficult.
Alternating ion exchange units have been successful for a very long time: they are cheap, and easy to operate. They don't require a chemical degree to operate for years.
If you just want to write a paper about your feasibility study, go ahead. If someone else is funding a study, a better result than just another paper should be expected.
Published by Waymon Hofheins
Thank you for your suggestion
Honestly, we want to see that can we use CEDI instead of ion exchange. However, the answers show that ion exchange is better and cheaper
Published by Amir Lashkari
That is distillation not destination. Automatic spell check is sometimes wrong.
Published by Waymon Hofheins
NO3 can remove easily by anoxic and annamox, for Electro dialysis or Technology nearby I think it will be complicated.
Published by AGGASIT DAD, Energy and Environmental including CDM and Innovation Project Consultant Freelancer
This water is drinking water and we cannot use bacteria methods for this
Published by Amir Lashkari
Amir! If nitrate is the only component to be removed, nitrate removal ion exchange resin would be more simple, effective and reasonable.
Published by Reza Nikbakht, Process Engineer
Thank you Reza
Published by Amir Lashkari
We use “Electro-Oxidation” Technology as a Pre-Treatment to RO Systems with very Good Results If you wish to learn more let me know as we have Proven Data
Published by Jim Patterson, President at RyKor LLC Water Technology & Pressure Vessel Rep / Consultant
Yes we have Commercial trailer units with capacity of 1250 gpm for large volume requirements. Email me Jim.patterson@rykor.net
Electro-Oxidation technology uses DC electricity to make TDS into “precipitatant” molecules/particles < 0.005 micron size & inert. 45 Families of Oxidants & > 400+ chain reactions created from waters
Published by Jim Patterson, President at RyKor LLC Water Technology & Pressure Vessel Rep / Consultant
Thank you
Published by Amir Lashkari
Thank you that seems good to learn about it if it is possible, I will be thankful
Published by Amir Lashkari
Hi Amir,
It's possible but not trivial one, we have 16 years experience re purifying wastewater / seawater into potable at low operating costs and zero emissions; properly it's no conventional EDI but we just use 100% renewable energy.
Published by Arturo Constante, Wastewater Purification - Zero Emissions
Hi Dear Amir
Such a plant for the continuous process will be so expensive. As Mr.Cheraghi mentioned, this process should be done after primary water treatment, RO or deionizing with exchange resins for instance as a polishing or finishing process, otherwise, it will not be feasible at all. You can also use ultra-pure mixed bed resins such as "UCW3700 of PUROLITE" for better results. Please find the datasheet at the link below:
https://www.purolite.com/product/ucw3700
Goodluck
Published by alireza Reyhan, Eng
Dear alireza
Thank you and this information helps me a lot, but the resin you mentioned is not suitable for our project because we need nitrate removal resin
Published by Amir Lashkari
Hi Amir
we used CEDI after single pass Ro or dual pass Ro for produce of demin. water. In this case the quality of water (TDS<10ppm)is very pure and after CEDI,we have ultra pure water with conductivity 0.006 micro siemens/cm2 .
Published by Ali Cheraghi
Well EDI or CDI is just a replacement of Mixed bed Ion Exchange process. EDI has its own requirements, Lot of removal before you come to EDI is required. Conductivity is Micromohos Cm which is equivalent to 18 Megohms -cm.
Published by C S Pradhyumna CEng MICE, MIMechE, Associate Director at PwC India
Dear ali would i ask your phone number? I like to talk about it with you and it will be my honor
Published by Amir Lashkari