If one had to select one fixed sampling location for physicochemical parameters in a large lake such as lake Malawi, how could he/she go about it?

Published by

In the 1940s a British scientist by name of Beauchamp located a fixed sampling station for physicochemical parameters 5 km north-east of Nkhata Bay in the northern offshore waters of Lake Malawi. The lake is about 400 metres deep at that Beauchamp's sampling station, but no details were given on why that location was considered representative of the whole lake.   I'm intending to do my sampling at that same location. However, as several years have lapsed after Beauchamp did his work and temporal changes may have occurred since then, and no clear reasons were given why that one location was considered representative I tend to hesitate. Could anyone help with a suggestion?

Tags

25 Answers

why you want to do this? If ...

why you want to do this?

If you want to compare the first (1940) results and yours....you have to do it in same site...for obvious reason.

If your study has other aims....then you consider the suggestions given...

sampling should either representative eg represent the lake water as a whole.

Many contributing factors are there affecting/contributing to water quality or other aspects.

M.I.Zuberi, Ethiopia

Published by

I would start with why test ...

I would start with why test at all? What are you trying to confirm or understand? Then you can make logical choices about where to locate (but I would agree, one fixed spot seems like of limited use, so preferably increase or make mobile with rotation to various fixed points on a schedule).

Published by

sampling location Hello ...

sampling location

Hello Beachamp,

the lake is quite big and it looks like there are several rivers feeding it. there is also a city near by, the influence of which can significantly modify your results if you will sample near Maleri island. If I would be you, I would sample at few locations and at different depth to see the differences with longitude.

good luck!

Published by

is the lake closed? is there ...

is the lake closed? is there any feeding river or regular rain? so you may need to consider water add-on rate. And what is the purpose of the tests? try to think about locations where they are close to the uses of the lake (maybe water intake?!).

Published by

generally, you don't use one ...

generally, you don't use one point. but i guess, he was doing a Q and D or quick and dirty. if i were to do it, you want an established point. doing it at the same point is better than starting at a new spot. perhaps its away from population..of around average depth.. and he thought it was representative of the lake..

Published by